Vortia 3D Open the app

Case study: dust extraction in a joinery workshop

Published on by Raul Rodríguez

Four machines, a bag filter and a centrifugal fan. In chip extraction, noise and pressure drop are not what matters most: what matters is that the air moves fast enough for the sawdust not to settle in the duct. It is the “Joinery workshop” example in the app.

Open this example in the app

1. The starting point

MachineAirflowOpening
Circular saw800 m³/hFlanged, 200 × 200 mm
Spindle moulder900 m³/hFlanged, 200 × 200 mm
Thicknesser1,300 m³/hFlanged, 250 × 250 mm
Planer1,100 m³/hFlanged, 250 × 250 mm

Typical catalogue airflows for industrial woodworking machines. Total: 4,100 m³/h.

A Ø315 main runs across the workshop and Ø200 drops come down from it to each machine. In front of the fan there is a bag filter with a 900 Pa pressure drop at its nominal airflow: it goes into the app as a “Fitting (known ΔP)”, with the manufacturer’s figure.

In “Installation”, the contaminant is “Heavy dust (chips, sand)”: ACGIH requires at least 20 m/s along the whole route. Wood dust is combustible, so ATEX is also ticked.

2. First calculation: the sawdust settles in the duct

MachineNeedsReceivesDeviation
Circular saw800 m³/h1,134 m³/h+42 %
Spindle moulder900 m³/h826 m³/h-8 %
Thicknesser1,300 m³/h606 m³/h-53 %
Planer1,100 m³/h1,534 m³/h+39 %

The air moves at between 5.4 m/s (the final run) and 14.6 m/s (the main): no component reaches 20 m/s. In the 3D view the sawdust can be seen dragging along the bottom of the horizontal runs. On top of that, the Thicknesser receives less than half of what it needs and the Saw and the Planer get 40 % too much.

3D view of the initial extraction network with sawdust settling in the horizontal runs
First calculation: below 20 m/s the dust drops to the bottom of the duct.

The transport velocity warnings are grouped into one, with a button per component to view it in 3D and another to size the network:

Vortia 3D warnings panel with the components below the transport velocity and the “Size the network” button
The warnings panel: every fix, one click away.

3. Sizing for the transport velocity

In industrial extraction, “Size the network” proposes the minimum transport velocity criterion by default: on each run, the largest Ø that keeps 20 m/s. Any larger and the sawdust settles; any smaller only adds pressure drop.

  • Main from Ø315 to Ø250, with three reducers as the airflow falls: Ø224, Ø200 and Ø125 at the Planer.
  • Drops from Ø200 to Ø112 (Saw), Ø125 (Spindle moulder) and Ø140 (Thicknesser).

All components now run at between 19.2 and 25.3 m/s. The fan goes from 1,184 to 2,169 Pa: moving fast costs pressure, and it is the price of not having to clean the ducts.

4. Balancing the dampers

One damper on each drop and another on the final run. “Balance dampers” closes them just enough for each machine to get its airflow:

MachineNeedsBalancedDeviationDropDamper
Circular saw800 m³/h799 m³/h-0.1 %Ø11219.5°
Spindle moulder900 m³/h902 m³/h+0.2 %Ø12521°
Thicknesser1,300 m³/h1,303 m³/h+0.2 %Ø1401.5°
Planer1,100 m³/h1,097 m³/h-0.3 %Ø1250°

Maximum error of 0.3 % and velocities between 20.4 and 24.8 m/s. The Planer, at the end of the main, stays open: it is the index branch. The fan needs 2,428 Pa.

3D view of the balanced extraction network, coloured by velocity
The balanced network: the whole route above 20 m/s.

In joinery workshops, machines that are not running are usually shut off completely. With fewer machines open, the velocity rises in their drops and falls in the main: it is worth also calculating the real diversity (open the project, remove the target airflow of the machines that are off and look at the velocities).

5. Fan and filter

  • Duty point: 4,155 m³/h (4,100 plus 55 of leakage) at 2,428 Pa. It is a medium-pressure centrifugal fan.
  • Pressure breakdown: the filter takes 900 Pa (37 %); each opening, between 120 and 180 Pa (ACGIH coefficient 0.49 on around 290 Pa of velocity pressure).
  • Electrical power: 4.7 kW with 70 % fan efficiency and 85 % for motor and drive.
  • Noise reaching the workshop through the ducts: 65–67 dB(A), below 80 dB(A) (Spanish RD 286/2006 on workplace noise). Noise from the machines and the fan itself is separate.

The specific fan power (SFP) of EN 16798-3 is for ventilation in buildings: in this example the limit is set at “SFP 7”, with no requirement.

6. ATEX

With the dust marked as combustible, the app recalls what the Spanish ATEX regulation (RD 681/2003) requires: fan and equipment to Directive 2014/34/EU for the classified zone, ducts earthed and explosion protection for the filter (venting, suppression or isolation). The explosion risk assessment is a separate document.

Summary

StepFan pressureVelocity along the routeMaximum airflow deviation
First calculation1,184 Pa5.4–14.6 m/s53 %
Sizing2,169 Pa19.2–25.3 m/s15 %
Balancing2,428 Pa20.4–24.8 m/s0.3 %